Sat 26 Dec 2009
Firefox, Chrome, or Safari…pros and cons?
Posted by Heidi under Internets
No Comments
And we dip back into the reader suggested topics for a not-so-regularly updated post. I promise I’ll write later to sort of explain where I’ve been. For realsies this time.
Anyway, who doesn’t get excited for a browser question?? Well, not me. I love this kind of stuff. Except for the whole part where in this case I have become such a fangirl that I don’t have a good answer.
In my prior life, when I used Windows, which was way way long ago, I used EverythingButIE. I can remember Netscape, I used Lynx occasionally (which really helped later) but the earliest incantations of the Mozilla Browser kingdom just weren’t out yet. There were others, I’m sure. I think I used Opera for a bit but never got into it. We’re cool, though, in a totally platonic way.
When I switched to Linux in 2002, I used KDE as my GUI desktop client. There was a browser with it called Konqueror which I loved. (Funny aside, while reading up on KDE vs GNOME, everybody everywhere was all about the GNOME. I hated it and thought the usability was severely lacking. For whatever reason, I didn’t cyber-stalk Linus Torvalds back then, but apparently he prefers KDE and encourages people to use it over GNOME. I totally thought like Torvalds for a split second which makes me cool. For realsies.) When I installed Debian Linux a few years in, early 2005, KDE was having some temporary issues if I recall. There was some reason that made me use GNOME and my mind doesn’t have those details right now but I vaguely remember KDE crap happening. However, before this switch, I had begun using the Mozilla browser products. I was a Phoenix/Firebird user. Yeah, I’m old school. That was around 2003 I think. There were some things that worked better with Konqueror and some things that worked better in Phoenix so I’d choose based on that. When I did switch over to GNOME, I had begun using what is now Firefox all the time.
Of course, throughout all of this I was working in tech support and being forced to use IE (or worse, the AOL browser for troubleshooting…and IE for my own browsing) all day every day. I hated it.
When I moved to Tampa, I used my roommate’s iBook a bit and kind of fell in love with OS X. I wasn’t entirely sold on Safari yet, though. I believe I used Camino a bit more in the beginning. Another fun aside: people who worked on Camino actually helped design Firefox and make it what it is today. Yay Camino.
I got my own iBook in early 2006 and primarily used Safari. But I downloaded just about every browser available for OS X back then. It was shortly after IE had been discontinued for Mac and at some point I remember having huge issues because I needed IE for something I was doing at home and couldn’t find a working copy. Then I found a super seekrit super old copy which didn’t work anyways. That is why IE fails. I honestly don’t remember everything I tried; all I’ve kept are Safari, Camino, Firefox and Opera. I mostly only use Safari but sometimes a site works better in Firefox so I keep it handy.
It should be noted that Firefox for Mac? Is clunky and kind of sucks ass. But. If I am using Windows? It’s Firefox all the way. I have actually hidden IE on the Windows machines in the house, forcing everyone to use Firefox. Makes it *so* much easier on me. I’ll also still use Firefox on Linux, though it’s been a while for me. Like years. I’m planning on reclaiming one of the desktops here to play around again. I had given my dad my old desktop and he gave my brother his. But my brother doesn’t live here and one computer sits unused. So, yeah. Mine again. It’s for science.
I honestly haven’t played with Chrome at all. I don’t spend enough time on any of the other computers to necessitate installing it and it only recently came out for Mac. Like in the past two weeks recently. And I’ve been too lazy to install it. I used to be an early adopter but…meh.
Now, saying all of this – I’ve never used Safari on Windows, or Chrome at all. Neither have a Linux version. So for portability purposes, I’d say that Firefox comes up on top in this battle. It has a strong history, a bajillion plugins (which I never use) and is cross-platform friendly. That is good in my book. But when it comes down to usability, I am a Mac girl and find that Safari is the best for Mac (unless Chrome proves me wrong.) I’ve had very little experience with Windows in the past 3 or 4 years – ever since I stopped doing tech support and started working in a data center – I stopped supporting the Windows environment and got to just use it as a workstation. I became like the millions of masses who come to work and just do work stuff. Except for when all the job duties went away and I just did Facebook stuff. Probably something unique to my situation. I’ve touched Windows Vista once and hope to never see it again. Never played with Windows 7, but from the pictures it looks a whole lot like an OS X clone. Funny one, Bill Gates.
I’ve seen increasing percentages of users visiting my site from Windows machines using Safari and that does make my Grinch-heart smile a bit. In a bwahahaha kind of way. Who knew the outspoken open source chick would turn into such a Mac fangirl? I guess it’s just that I like the way everything works. And not only works, but is absolutely beautiful while it does your bidding. I mean, seriously – Safari unquestionably has the best rendering engine of all the browsers in the wild today which leads to a pleasant experience. How long has it been since you’ve thought of time with your computer as a pleasant experience? Outside of pr0n, of course.
So, for me on my Mac, it’s Safari. And unless major changes are afoot, it will remain Safari. I will eventually try out Chrome but will probably wait until I get a new laptop. Old Euclid doesn’t like change much, he’s kind of like a cranky old man. For cross-compatibility, clearly the choice is Firefox. Though don’t get deluded into thinking it’s necessarily the best because it has issues. I do have really high hopes for Chrome but doubt I’ll get to see it in different environments so it’s hard to say for that one. I want to like it though. But, it’s probably too early to tell in its current form.
I will say, Phoenix/Firebird? Totally fucking rocked. For realsies.
Update: I did actually install and use Chrome last night. I liked it, I really did. And it didn’t make the angry spinny ball show up once. But I realized one of the huge reasons I use Safari – other than it’s pretty and works well (as a general rule.) Built in RSS reader. Sure, I use Google Reader sometimes. But, I’m lazy. You know that. I like having a browser that automagically alerts me when there’s been an update to something I read. It does some other things that I really like, but apparently Chrome does them too. Like the most visited sites thumbnail/link displaying when I open a new tab or window. And the dragging an opened tag into its own window pretty damn seamlessly.
So, again, it’s Safari forevers for me.
